A dog expert has issued a cautionary statement to young families considering adding a furry companion, highlighting certain dog breeds that may be more difficult to manage around infants and toddlers.
Breed-Specific Considerations for Families with Young Children
Niki French, a professional dog trainer and founder of PupTalk, has advised parents to carefully consider the temperament of dog breeds before bringing them into a household with small children. While she emphasizes that “there’s no such thing as a bad dog,” French explains that certain breeds may prove challenging in the family environment, particularly those with high energy levels or instinctual behaviors that are difficult to manage.
Interestingly, French points to Border Collies as a breed that can be especially demanding for families. Known for their herding abilities, Border Collies may exhibit behaviors like nipping at people’s heels or attempting to herd family members. These instincts, while useful in agricultural settings, can be difficult to manage in a home with young, excitable children.
“There is no such thing as a bad dog, only a dog in the wrong environment,” French stated. “Genetics and early socialization play a huge role in a dog’s temperament, but certain breeds, like the working Border Collie, may struggle to adapt to a family dynamic, especially with toddlers.”
Other Breeds to Approach with Caution
In addition to Border Collies, French also cautioned against breeds that tend to bark excessively, such as Chihuahuas, Yorkshire Terriers, and hounds. These breeds’ tendency to bark can be distressing to small children, especially when combined with the noise of a crying baby or a restless toddler. French recommends that parents also consider the prey drive of certain breeds, such as English Foxhounds and Border Terriers, which may be difficult to manage around small children due to their instinct to chase.
“Some dogs are naturally inclined to bark more, and young children may find that unsettling,” French added. “It’s also important to recognize that the noise and chaos of a busy home can be overwhelming for some dogs.”
Training and Environment Matter
Despite her concerns, French stresses the importance of proper training and consistent socialization in ensuring a positive relationship between dogs and children. With patience, time, and kindness, families can successfully integrate a dog into their home, regardless of breed.
“Training can work wonders in helping dogs and children coexist peacefully,” she noted. “However, it’s crucial to recognize that not every dog, regardless of breed, will be comfortable in a lively household.”
The Bigger Picture
French’s advice comes amid growing concerns about dangerous dog breeds, especially following the UK’s 2024 ban on XL Bullies in England and Wales. While French attributes the risk associated with XL Bullies to irresponsible breeding and ownership, she emphasizes that the behavior of any dog, regardless of size, can be influenced by its upbringing.
“Bigger dogs obviously have stronger jaws, and while some are gentle giants, smaller breeds can still cause harm if they feel threatened,” she explained.
Jeanette Muldoon from The Family Dog Club also pointed out that a dog’s behavior is not solely determined by its upbringing, noting that dogs, like people, can have good and bad days. “It’s a myth that all problematic dogs come from bad owners,” Muldoon stated. “Dogs have emotions, and their behavior can be unpredictable, especially if they’ve had traumatic experiences.”
In light of these insights, both experts agree that potential dog owners must be vigilant and aware of breed-specific traits, ensuring that their pets are a good fit for their family dynamic.